What material would allow us to make a dog house that is cool in summer and warm in winter?
Wood
Introducing the topic
The first important message of this unit is that purpose comes before choice of material. Once we know the purpose of whatever product it is we want to produce, we can decide what properties we need the building material to have, and then choose a material that possesses those properties.
In the first unit of Matter and Materials, we distinguish between materials that are metallic and those that are not. Although this is not a formal definition, we group everything that is not metallic into the category of non-metals. We make the distinction between metals and non-metals on the basis of properties, and so it is important to establish a firm understanding of the term properties early on.
You could start with a conversation about building something new (like the dog house example below), then steer the conversation towards properties by asking questions around the ways in which the object will be used.
In this chapter we will learn about metals and non-metals. Do you remember learning about materials in Grade 4. Metals and non-metals are two different classes of materials. Each class has its own unique properties. Properties are the things that are special or unique about an object or a material. We can use the properties of a material to describe what it is like. For example, we could say that a property of a gas is that it can be compressed.
When we want to make a new product (a building or a tool or any kind of object) we first have to decide what the purpose of that product will be. Perhaps we want to make a tool for digging in the garden, or a kennel (dog house) for our new puppy. The purpose of the product will help us decide which would be the best material with which to make the object.
What would be the best material for a digging tool? Surely we would need a tool that is strong and durable; with a sharp edge that will allow us to cut through the soil when we dig into it.
What material would allow us to make a dog house that is cool in summer and warm in winter?
Wood
What material would you choose to make a spade for digging in the garden?
Metal or hard plastic
The next activity is about the things we think about when we choose materials for a specific purpose. In this case the purpose is building a house.
The purpose of the activity is for learners to discover that there are many options to choose from when choosing materials for a particular job, and that circumstances may dictate which material would be the best choice. For instance, the learners are required to say which material (corrugated iron or wood) would be best suited for a house located next to the ocean. They should be encouraged to think about aspects such as corrosion (which will be dealt with in greater detail later) and thermal conductivity (also covered later) which would make wood the better choice. Availability and cost are also aspects that could be brought into the conversation. How available is corrugated iron vs wood?
INSTRUCTIONS:
QUESTIONS:
What material was used to build house A?
House A is made of corrugated iron (tin/metal).
What material was used to build house B?
House B is made of wood.
If you had to build a house next to the ocean, which one would you choose, house A or house B?
House B
Teacher note: House B would be a better choice, but house A is not wrong. Read the suggested answer to the next question to see why B is the better choice.
Write down a reason why you would build this house next to the ocean rather than the other one.
Metal objects usually rust in the wet, salty air close to the ocean. That would make a corrugated iron house a poor choice. Metals are also good conductors of heat, which would make the iron house cold inside when the outside temperature is cold, and hot inside when the weather is hot.
Teacher note: House B (the wooden house) would be the best choice, provided that wood is cheaply available. Often people build tin houses because it is the cheapest material available.
Write down at least three other materials that could be used for building a house.
Bricks, reeds, concrete, hard plastic sheets (any durable, waterproof material would be suitable.)
Now that we have looked at the different types of materials that you could use to build a house and seen that there are different cases when you would use one material or another, let's look at the actual properties of metals and non-metals.
In this section learners will investigate and contrast the properties of metals and materials that are not metallic (so-called 'non-metals'). You could draw their attention to metallic and non-metallic items in the classroom, or in pictures, as an introduction to the topic and related activities.
Explanation of the new words to be covered in this section, associated with metals.
Good question Tom! Let's look at the properties of metals. A property is a word used to describe a material or object and tells us something about it.
Here, the conversation could be directed in such a way that learners realise that when we cook food, we heat the outside of the pot, the food cooks on the inside. That means the heat that cooks the food travels through the metal. Would heat travel through plastic in the same way? No, the plastic would melt. Would heat travel through wood in the same way? No, the wood would burn.
Do not worry Tom! These are new, big words, but here is an activity in which we can investigate some of the properties of metals. We will use our skills of observation (looking, listening and touching) during the investigation.
Here, a comment about skills of observation may be appropriate. What are skills of observation? What does it mean to observe something? Does observation only refer to things we can see? No, we can also observe (hear) sounds, observe (smell) odours, observe (feel) textures and observe (taste) flavours. Learners might also find it difficult to express what they observe. Encourage them to find words to write down, or say what they see, hear, smell, feel and taste. This will help to develop their science vocabulary.
This activity is ideal for small group work. Learners could discuss their observations in the group and fill in the table of observations together. Learners may need help finding words for what they are observing. For this reason a word box is provided, but learners could also be encouraged to use their own words. Since this is an investigation, there are no right or wrong answer, as long as learners can justify their answers from their own observations. Rather learners should be encouraged to discover freely, and then link descriptive words to their observations. At the end of both investigations (Theproperties of metals and The properties of non-metals) they should be able to compile a list of the general properties of metals and non-metals similar to the lists given at the end of this unit.
Tom identified a problem and a question - he wants to experience the properties of metals. In a science investigation we want to answer a question or find something out.
What would you like to find out in this investigation? (We call this the aim of the investigation.)
MATERIALS:
METHOD:
shiny, dull, rough, hard, smooth, makes a ringing sound, cold, warm, heavy, rigid, sharp, flexible, soft, light |
OBSERVATIONS:
Name of the object |
How the object feels when I touch it |
What the object looks like |
The sound that is made when the object is tapped or dropped |
CONCLUSION:
What have you learned from investigating the properties of metals?
Remember when we looked at the two different houses made from tin and wood? Metals are used to make objects because of the properties that they have.
INSTRUCTIONS:
Describe the properties of the metal that this pot is made from.
The pot is shiny, strong and hard, it conducts heat, and only melts at very high temperatures
Why are some of the properties useful to the function of the pot.
Being strong and hard is useful as the pot needs to be able to carry food and you do not want it to break or shatter if you put it down hard on a surface. The metal conducts heat which is useful to cooking food (heat conductivity of metals is only meant to be introduced in the next chapter, but it can be mentioned here.) But the pot also will not melt as metals only melt at very high temperatures, much higher than the highest temperature the stove is able to reach.
This fence in the next photo is made from metal wire. What property of metal allows us to make this barbed wire fence from metal?
Metal is ductile meaning it can be made into thin wires without breaking, which is why we can make barbed wire.
What properties does a spanner need to have in order to be used to tighten bolts?
The spanner must be hard and strong.
How do the properties of metal help the functioning of a spanner?
The metal is strong and hard and the spanner needs to be strong and hard. The metal will not break when trying to tighten a bolt.
If the spanner was made from plastic, do you think it would work as well? Why?
A plastic spanner would not work so well as it would easily break. Plastic is not as strong or hard as metal.
This is because metals are hard and strong. Coins need to be hard and strong as they are often in a wallet where they bump against other coins, they are put into machines, such as to pay for parking, they might be slammed down on a counter when buying something. All these actions make it necessary for coins to be durable, so that they won't break easily. Coins are therefore made from metal.
This structure is made from sheets of corrugated iron metal. What property of metal allows people to make sheets of metal like this?
Metal is malleable meaning it can be hammered and shaped into thin sheets of metal.
We have said that metals are shiny (they have lustre). But sometimes, when metal gets old it becomes dull. If something is dull, it has lost its shine. There are ways to make metals shiny again.
The purpose of this activity is for learners to investigate ways to make metals shiny again - do not tell them directly what to do, but rather let them investigate and find out for themselves. They can then write up the activity after completing it. Materials to bring to class are old cloths, Brasso, coins, old pots, a bowl of water. Try and bring some metal objects to school which are old and dull, especially old metal pots which you may have at home. Place the objects in front of the learners and ask them to find the best way to make a metal object shiny again. Let them compare rubbing with a cloth, rubbing with a cloth dipped in water and rubbing with a cloth with some Brasso.
INSTRUCTIONS:
QUESTIONS:
What question were you trying to answer in this investigation?
How can you make a metal object shiny again? How can you clean dirty copper coins or pots?
Write the list of materials that you needed for this activity. Write it in a bulleted list.
Imagine you had to tell the Thunderbolt kids how to do this activity to answer your question. Write down the steps to follow in order to complete this activity. Use your experience from experimenting with the objects to come up with a method for the activity. Remember to number the steps in the method.
Assess the learner's ability to record what they did and write short, brief sentences. You might want to start them off with the first step, depending on what you did in class. For example it might be: "Examine an old, dull metal object such as a coin or old pot", the step 2 is "Rub a spot on the surface of the object with a cloth to see if you can make it shiny again", then step 3 "Dip the cloth in water and rub a different spot on the surface of the object, or a different coin", and step 4 "Pour some brasso onto the cloth and rub this onto another spot on the surface of the object. Let the Brasso dry and then polish it off", etc
What can you conclude was the best and quickest way to make dull metal shiny again?
Something about the fact that rubbing with a cloth and brasso is the best way to make a dull metal object shiny again.
Explanation of new words in this section
Non-metals are materials that do not have the same properties as metals.
This conversation could be linked to an earlier conversation in which learners were helped to discover that metals are good conductors of heat ("when we cook food, we heat the outside of the pot, but the food cooks on the inside'). That means the heat can also travel along the handle of the pot or pan and burn our hands. Would heat travel through plastic or wood in the same way? No, the plastic or wood acts as insulator, to protect our hands from the heat. These materials do not conduct heat well. Learners could also be reminded that a hot pot or pan could also be handled with a thick cloth or oven mitt to protect the hands. Cloth does not conduct heat well either.
In the next activity we will investigate some of the properties of non-metals. We will test and observe the non-metals in the same way that we tested the metals in the previous activity. This is so that we can compare metals and non-metals later on.
This activity is ideal for small group work. Learners could discuss their observations in the group and fill in the table of observations together. Learners may need help finding words for what they are observing. For this reason a word box is provided, but learners could also be encouraged to use their own words. Since this is an investigation, there are no right or wrong answers. Rather learners should be encouraged to discover freely, and then link descriptive words to their observations. At the end of both investigations (The properties of metals and The properties ofnon-metals) they should be able to compile a list of the general properties of metals and non-metals similar to the lists given at the end of this unit.
AIM: What do you want to find out by doing this investigation.
I want to find out about the properties of non-metals.
MATERIALS:
METHOD:
shiny, dull, rough, hard, smooth, makes a ringing sound, cold, warm, heavy, rigid, sharp, flexible, soft, light |
OBSERVATIONS:
Fill in the observations from your investigation of different non-metals below.
Name of the object |
How the object feels when I touch it |
What the object looks like |
The sound that is made when the object is tapped or dropped |
What have we learnt about the properties of metals and non-metals? Now we are ready to compare the properties of metals and non-metals. Read through the two lists below. Do you agree with the properties that have been listed? Are there other properties that you would like to add?
Metals are (mostly):
Non-metals:
What does the word "property" mean?
Properties are the things that are special about an object or a material. The properties of a material tells us what it is like.
How can we tell if something is made of metal?
Things that are made of metal is shiny, and hard and they can sometimes feel heavy.
What does it mean to 'use our skills of observation'?
Skills of observation are looking, listening and touching. Smelling and tasting are also forms of observation.
Design an investigation in which you are trying to work out whether an object is made of metal or a non-metal. You do not need to write out the materials and apparatus required. Rather, explain in a paragraph about the different types of tests you would do to determine if something is made of a metal or a non-metal.
Learners must use their experience from the investigations to explore the properties of metals and non-metals in this chapter, and from designing their own investigation with the Brasso and dull metals. They should explain some tests to do and the result from the test will say whether it is a metal or not. For example, they could drop the object on the floor to see if it is brittle or not (not all non-metals are brittle though), they could see whether the surface is dull (non-metal) or shiny (metal), they could see whether the object is strong and hard (metal) or soft and bendy (non-metal). But it is important to point out that you cannot just do one of these tests to make a conclusion as there will be some exceptions, such as plastic is hard and smooth like a metal, but it is brittle. So learners need to do more than one test to make a conclusion. This is explored further in the next question.
Sometimes, just using one property to classify an object or material as a metal or non-metal might not be enough. For example, plastic is flexible but strong, so does this make it a metal? The answer is no. Another example is glass. Glass is also hard, but is it strong? What other properties does glass have which make it a non-metal and not a metal?
Glass is not strong, as it is brittle and can crack and break easily. It does not have the lustre of metal, and it can't be hammered into flat sheets or made into thin wires (it is not malleable or ductile).